UPDATE 12/24:I reordered as this has become my favorite liner. I notice a slight shade difference. In photos, the new shade swatch is below the old swatch. This new batch is more iridescent with gold and peach shine. The last order was more pink and matte and blurring. I prefer the old batch. Even the pencil itself is a different shade so I believe it's a new manufacturer. I bought from same seller. Original: I think I heard about this product on a viral hype site so my expectations were high. I boughtt he color 01: Touch Me. It is a pale brick and much lighter than the listing photo looked to me. Right now I am into "gym lips" or "lip blushing" which is meant to look like your natural lips but better. This lipliner is perfect for that. It is a little darker than my natural lips which are pale. It is creamy and goes on easily. It blends with lipstick or chapstick or gloss. It twists up but also has a sharpener which I think is odd if you can twist it up but may be useful if you want a sharp line. I give it a 10 out of 10 for creaminess. It is really smooth. It doesn't irritate or block my skin pores. It is matte and a nice shade. For longevity I give it a 5. Some liners last TOO long and give you the old lady line after your lipstick wears off, but this won't do that. It isn't great on longevity but that's my only beef. It is also a little on the pricey side for a no-name brand (that I know of) but that's a minor point. I've used it about 40 times and it hasn't run out so hopefully it will last a while longer. I would recommend it. I wish they had a multi pack for a good price to test out the other colors. My normal lipliner is BE bareMinerals Gen Nude Under Over Lip Liner, Borderline, and this color not unlike that one. This product is smaller but creamier than the BE product. Read more

One of my favorites! It used to be $5 so I was sad to see it went up to $10! All in all very creamy and goes on smooth. Need to reapply often and does smear unfortunately so I would say the longevity isn’t that great. Even with the price increase, you can’t beat it and it’s been one of my favorites for a few years now! Read more

personally a little too light for my skin tone but very pretty and glides well Read more

This lasts a long time and I like the color, but Dont remove it with your bare hands it stained my fingers even though I allowed it to dry for a while. Next time I used tweezers Read more

Very nice subtle color and the lip oil is glossy without being thick or sticky. Peel off lip stains are a bit tricky, but once you get the hang of it, they are great. Work from the outer edges of your lips in, apply thicker at the edges, keep lips dry while product sets. I use my fingernail to peel each lip from top to bottom/bottom to top- it’s easier than side to side. Any darker spots come off with water. Apply the gloss ( any Gloss or oil) and go. This can be a liner or all over lip color. Read more

Doesn’t glide easily with applying as it’s too rubbery, therefore the color won’t spread evenly. The result has nothing to do with the pictures attached! Read more