It’s a very creamy, thin point mechanical pencil and I love that so much. Application is flawless! Unfortunately, it is not smudge proof. Unless every part of skin around your eye is oil-less, this pencil needs to be set. You should treat it as if it were just a regular pencil. When I draw on the skin of my hand, it hardly budges, but something about the eye area breaks down the pencil. Frustrating. This was my first experience with a Japanese brand, and hoped it would give me better luck than waterproof American brands, but I’ve actually faired better with the American brands. Back to the drawing board! Read more

Easy to use and doesn’t smudge! Lasts long too! Read more

I do love this it’s great if you’re having issues with your waterlines smudging. Great quality overall I’ve always loved canmake. Read more

This is the best thin eyeliner pencil I have ever used. It is not waterproof but it is super long lasting and smudge proof. The texture is creamy and the color is opaque. It is easy to apply and easy to get a thin and sharp wing. Read more

4.7 stars. Got the black. So far, so great! I tested my eyeliner by leaving it on overnight (I know, kinda gross- don’t judge) but I have hooded eyelids and oily skin (and my eyes get watery in the am) so I use all of that to test the staying power on my eyeliners. They need to be smudge proof, budge proof, and water proof. And so far, this one is doing so good. Another thing, pigment is excellent- very black. Ease of glide was good too, not super creamy but not hard to put on either. The thinness of the pencil makes it super easy to draw my winged eyes. Buuuut, that is also the reason I would take off .3 stars. Since it is so thin I don’t know how long this eyeliner will last me and wonder if I would have to buy another one sooner rather than later, you know?! Value matters. But quality can trump it- even just a little hehe. Also, if the maker of this product could make a fatter version of this exact eyeliner, I would buy that too. It would make filling in parts of my eyeliner more easy and I wouldn’t feel like I’m overusing my thin pencil. Will update again once I use it some more. (Photo is after overnight test) Read more